“Truth is Truth” – Alex Toth on Carmine Infantino

In today’s day and age when all we hear is praise from one professional to another, it’s worth remembering that, sometimes, creators in the comic book industry just don’t get along for whatever reason. This previously unseen letter from Alex Toth to a friend of his (I’m not at liberty to reveal the name of the recipient) is a classic case. The only thing removed from this letter is text totally unrelated to the subject at hand. The letter was written in January 1976, shortly after Jenette Kahn took over from Carmine Infantino as DC Comics publisher. Toth and Infantino went back to the late 1940s when they both began working at DC. Joe Kubert had rented an apartment and used it as a studio, sharing the space with Toth along with other artists such as Irwin Hansen and Frank Giacoia. Infantino never worked there, but often visited and recounted several times later how the artists, and others, would socialise and discuss each other’s work. While at DC Tot