Art: Recreation vs Copying; Part III: Michael Golden

Considering the storm that is now raging it seemed apt enough that I added this one to the art recreation files. What you're seeing is the iconic cover for The Amazing Spider-Man #300 as drawn by Todd McFarlane. McFarlane no longer draws Spider-Man, but his work on that title overshadows anything he's done before, or since (including Spawn) for the majority of the people out there. One thing that McFarlane did bring to the title was a new approach. For better or worse, his exaggerated style made the title popular once more and breathed new life into the character.

That book came out in May 1988.

What you're seeing here is one of the pieces of cover art as done by Michael Golden for the cover to the Heroes Convention 2007 program. It's already been pointed out that the image isn't so much of an 'influence' than it appears to be a straight copy. The question remains, why would an artist of Michael's talent resort to copying the art of someone that has always pointed to him as a major influence? Michael, or Renee, may deny the swipe charge, but seriously, the images are pretty damn close.

You decide. As a now defunct web-site used to ask; Swipe, Homage or Coincidence?

Comments

SanctumSanctorumComix said…
Golden stated that since he and Todd are friends, and that, indeed, Todd wrote the introduction to one of Michael's art-books, that it would be nice to homage Todd's famous Spidey cover.

It was all out in the open.
Nothing deceitful or suspicious about it at all.

I also remember way back, nearly a decade ago, an interview with Golden (Wizard mag?) he stated that if he were to have a protege' (I think he actually used the words "someone who could be "my kid") it would be Todd McFarlane.

~P~
P-TOR
Wednesday, August 08, 2007 3:37:00 am
Danny said…
That's not homage, it's a straight copy, pure and simple, nothing more, nothing less.
Wednesday, August 08, 2007 5:47:00 am
Post a Comment

Previous Posts!

Show more

Popular posts from this blog

MARVEL COMICS DEMANDS $17,000 from BROKE CREATOR of GHOST RIDER! The Shame Of Marvel...Part II

Image
The final judgement has been handed down in the long running Gary Friedrich vs Marvel (Ghost Rider) case, and now we know the full amount that Friedrich owes Marvel.  That's right, Marvel, a company that stands to make millions of dollars from the upcoming Ghost Rider II movie, and is paying Nicholas Cage millions to portray a character that Friedrich created, now wants money from Friedrich - in specific $17,000.  And they'd like that $17,000 now, please.  In full.

This stipulation has been agreed upon and so ordered by the court, with the final judgement reflecting all that contained within.  This now means that Gary Friedrich has the right to appeal, and appeal he shall, but it also means that he now owes Marvel Comics, a multi-million dollar making machine, backed by the multi-billion dollar Disney company, $17,000 and cannot ever sell anything related to Ghost Rider, nor can he even say that he created Ghost Rider for any form of gain or advertising.  Well done Marvel!!  …
Read more

Yogi Bear's Sexuality Explained

Image
Was Yogi Bear gay or not? It's this kind of thing that keeps me wide awake in the middle of the night, clutching at the quilt, drowning in sweat and wishing that the ghosts inside of my head would just flee and leave me be. But they don't, so I instantly turn my thoughts into other realms.

Now, Yogi. On the surface of things he appears to be a normal bear. In the historical context of things he's just a cheap copy of Art Carney's Ed Norton (actually the Honeymooners was stolen better by Warner Brothers for their cartoon series featuring mice - Ralphy boy and his neighbour Martin).

Yogi used to hang around a place called Jellystone National Park and was, for the most part, obsessed by picnic baskets. Like a demented homeless person he relentlessly stalked people, slept on park benches, probably urinated in public, harassed people and stole whatever food and anything else that he could reach. All the time he was pursued by two people, the first being the anal retentive Ra…
Read more

New York Scam: A Serious Warning For All Travellers

Be warned - read this, take note and learn the easy way - we've learnt this lesson the hard way.

As people who read this stuff on some form of a regular basis might be aware we're off to New York in just over a month. Three weeks in New York, one week in San Fransisco. The key, for us anyway, is booking some decent accommodation, so we decided that, as we're going to be in New York for three weeks solid, that we'd go for a serviced apartment over a hotel room. So we started looking on the proper web-sites for places until we found one. Great location, it does exist, great photos - the lot. Perfect for our needs. The other half made contact with the 'owner' via the web-site and made arrangements to pay. We were asked to pay via MoneyGram, no biggie and no alarm bells started to ring - we've not done this before and all seemed normal. We made the first payment and got an email back from the 'owner' saying he'd gotten the payment and could we fix th…
Read more